Poor market timing sees investors lose money in thematic funds

Sustainable funds newThematic funds have yielded “disappointing” returns in the past five years – particularly energy transition funds - but poor judgement by investors is to blame.

Fund data provider Morningstar said there had been a “concerning trend” in the thematic funds sector, which has more than doubled its global assets under management since 2018, driven by interest in themes such as AI and ageing populations.

Poorly timed buys and sells saw investors lose more than two-thirds of total returns, the firm said in its ‘The Big Shortfall’ report.

Thematic funds delivered average total returns of 7.3% annualised over the five-year period ending on June 30, 2023. Yet investors earned only a 2.4% return when the impact of cash inflows and outflows was considered.

This means investors suffered a 4.9 percentage point annual return shortfall that stemmed from mistimed purchases and sales.

A combination of volatile return profiles, low- or no-commission trading, and intraday trading capabilities in thematic ETFs “can encourage the worst type of investor behaviour”, resulting in poor investment outcomes, Morningstar’s report said.

Kenneth Lamont, senior manager research analyst at Morningstar, said: “As a global cohort, thematic funds have yielded disappointing investor returns over the past five years, with a staggering 4.9% investment gap. Unfortunately, the narrative is one of poor timing, as over two-thirds of total returns slipped away.”

Return gaps were far wider in ETFs than in thematic mutual funds due partly to ETFs' tendency to be more concentrated.  

“Investors, collectively, have shown themselves to be poor market-timers, especially when buying and selling more targeted volatile funds compared to their more diversified counterparts,” said Lamont.

A case in point is the iShares Global Clean Energy ETF pair – which has Europe and US-listed versions - and saw $5.8 billion of inflows between November 2020 and January 2021 following strong performance that was probably linked to Joe Biden’s election to US president in the third quarter of 2020.

The new investments didn’t benefit from the preceding months’ gains. While the index tracked by the ETFs returned 17.6% annualised in the period of study, the annualised return for investors who bought the funds over the same period was a negative 5.5%.

This means there was a “colossal” 23% investment gap between what the fund returned and what investors got, says the Morningstar report, noting the strategy has lost half its value.

“The large return gap seen across the thematic fund universe years can broadly be characterized as one large binary bet that went wrong,” the report concludes.

Lamont urges investors to be more patient and disciplined and said a buy-and-hold thematic strategy is more likely to deliver superior outcomes for most investors.

© 2023 funds europe

Thought leadership


As the damage from extreme weather events becomes more apparent, this research from S&P Global seeks to measure the financial costs of climate hazards on corporate assets in different sectors & geographies.


2024 will be a year of multiple transitions in the global economy and markets. Find out how to seize the opportunities and manage risks.



What should investors expect in 2024?

For the year ahead we expect lower growth, lower inflation and limited interest rate easing. Find out more in AXA IM’s Outlook 2024.

Ocorian switching admins native

Why are managers switching fund administrator?

13% of alternative fund managers are looking to switch their fund administrator over the next 18 months. Find out why.



This whitepaper outlines key challenges impeding the growth of private markets and explores how technological innovation, when bolstered by the operational experience and global reach of FMIs, can provide solutions to unlock access to private market funds for a growing investor base.


Transporting goods by sea is the lowest carbon way of transporting goods. That said, the shipping sector contribute 3% of global carbon emissions, so we need it to get to net zero. Breakthrough technologies have the power to reshape the industry and drastically reduce its environmental footprint.


Executive Video Interviews

Why fund admin tech is a key competitive advantage

Cian Hyland, Strategic Client Relationship Director at Deep Pool Financial Solutions spoke to us about how technology enables efficient data management, reporting automation and secure data access.

Insights from State Street

Cuan Coulter, Global Head of Asset Managers and Head of UK and Ireland at State Street, discusses how fund managers decide between the two cross-border fund domiciles, namely Ireland and Luxembourg, and why asset managers find managing data so difficult.

Unlocking access to private markets

Vincent Clause, who heads the global funds strategy at Euroclear and David Genn, CEO of Goji, sit down with Funds Europe to explain how technological innovation, bolstered by operational experience and global reach, can provide solutions that unlock access to private markets.

Sustainable investing in the DC world

Claire Felgate, a specialist in UK defined contribution pension schemes at asset manager BlackRock, talks with Funds Europe editor Nick Fitzpatrick about how - and the pace at which - DC pension schemes are adapting to the requirements of sustainable investment.



Watch our webinar for a deep dive into the findings of the fresh-off-the-press EU Taxonomy 2023 Insights Report, based on Clarity AI's best-in-class coverage of EU Taxonomy reported data and CDP industry-leading environmental datasets. 

In this webinar, we discuss tools for optimising fund data management and distribution, the role of global fund classifications and ratings, and how technology and automation enhance data integrity and insights.