Top 10 misconceptions about smart beta

The stratospheric rise of smart beta has provoked intense debate in recent years. Edhec Risk Institute feel much of this debate has been driven by misconceptions about smart beta strategies. The institute has now published a list of the most common misconceptions about smart beta, in three separate areas of smart beta performance and risk. They are as follows:
Performance drivers
  • The hiding game: “smart beta generates alpha”
  • The monkey portfolio claim: “anything beats cap-weighted market indices”
  • The value and size myth: “all smart beta performance comes from value and small-cap exposure”
  • The rebalancing fantasy: “smart beta outperforms because it trades against mean reversion”

Investability hurdles
  • The liquidity concern: “smart beta requires positions to be held in highly illiquid stocks”
  • The turnover critique: “smart beta necessarily leads to high turnover”
  • The crowding hypothesis: “if everyone knows about smart beta the benefits will disappear“

Strategy design choices
  • The concentration fallacy: “a good factor index should provide a strong tilt to the desired factor”
  • The factor fishing licence: “a good factor index requires a sophisticated scoring approach”
  • The factor purity argument: “a good factor index needs to isolate exposure to the target factor”

The firm’s analysis shows that more often than not, superficially convincing claims about smart beta strategies are in fact erroneous. Challenging conventional wisdom by reviewing academic literature and empirical evidence, the institute believes, will lead to more balanced conclusions and a more nuanced understanding of the benefits and risks of smart beta strategies. ©2016 funds europe

Executive Interviews

INTERVIEW: Put your money where your mouth is

Jun 10, 2016

At Kempen Capital Management, they believe portfolio managers should invest in their own funds. David Stevenson talks to Lars Dijkstra, CIO of the €42 billion manager.

EXECUTIVE INTERVIEW: ‘Volatility is the name of the game’

May 13, 2016

Axa Investment Managers chief executive officer, Andrea Rossi, talks to David Stevenson about bringing all his firm’s subsidiaries under one name and the opportunities that a difficult market...


ROUNDTABLE: Beyond the hype

Oct 13, 2016

The use of smart beta investing continues to grow. Our panel, made up of both providers and users, discusses what the strategy actually means, how it should be used and the kind of pitfalls that may arise when using this innovative investment technique.

MIFID II ROUNDTABLE: Following the direction of travel

Sep 07, 2016

Fund management firms Aberdeen and HSBC Global meet with specialist providers to speak about how the industry is evolving towards MiFID II.