Top 10 misconceptions about smart beta

The stratospheric rise of smart beta has provoked intense debate in recent years. Edhec Risk Institute feel much of this debate has been driven by misconceptions about smart beta strategies. The institute has now published a list of the most common misconceptions about smart beta, in three separate areas of smart beta performance and risk. They are as follows:
Performance drivers
  • The hiding game: “smart beta generates alpha”
  • The monkey portfolio claim: “anything beats cap-weighted market indices”
  • The value and size myth: “all smart beta performance comes from value and small-cap exposure”
  • The rebalancing fantasy: “smart beta outperforms because it trades against mean reversion”

Investability hurdles
  • The liquidity concern: “smart beta requires positions to be held in highly illiquid stocks”
  • The turnover critique: “smart beta necessarily leads to high turnover”
  • The crowding hypothesis: “if everyone knows about smart beta the benefits will disappear“

Strategy design choices
  • The concentration fallacy: “a good factor index should provide a strong tilt to the desired factor”
  • The factor fishing licence: “a good factor index requires a sophisticated scoring approach”
  • The factor purity argument: “a good factor index needs to isolate exposure to the target factor”

The firm’s analysis shows that more often than not, superficially convincing claims about smart beta strategies are in fact erroneous. Challenging conventional wisdom by reviewing academic literature and empirical evidence, the institute believes, will lead to more balanced conclusions and a more nuanced understanding of the benefits and risks of smart beta strategies. ©2016 funds europe

Sponsored Profiles

SPONSORED FEATURE: Alternative thinking

Mar 16, 2017

Portfolio Manager Davide Cataldo discusses the results of the Pioneer Investments’ survey on liquid alternatives and how investors can be encouraged to increase their allocation.

SPONSORED FEATURE: Interest rate risk hedging: Swapping to other options

Mar 16, 2017

Heightened margin requirements for cleared and uncleared OTC derivatives pose a challenge for legitimate hedging activities and are driving financial institutions to explore alternative hedging...

SPONSORED FEATURE: Why blockchain could be the fund industry’s next Ford Model T

Mar 16, 2017

Blockchain aims to radically change the way investors can access funds, says Olivier Portenseigne, Managing Director and Chief Commercial Officer of Fundsquare.

SPONSORED FEATURE: Open architecture: In need of protection

Mar 16, 2017

Greater efficiency must be embraced to ensure regulatory changes do not destroy choice for fund buyers, says Bernard Tancré of Clearstream.

Executive Interviews

CEO INTERVIEW: Munro gains three-year track record

Mar 16, 2017

Aviva Investors’ annual results this month were the third set since Euan Munro took over as CEO. Nick Fitzpatrick speaks to him about the ‘Aims’ fund at the heart of the firm’s outcome strategy.

DISTRIBUTION INTERVIEW: Tales of the unexpected

Mar 16, 2017

Laurence Terryn, a fund selector at Candriam, tells David Stevenson how the twists and turns of the past year’s macro environment flavoured her approach to fund selection.

Roundtables

ASSET SERVICING ROUNDTABLE: Under pressure

Mar 07, 2017

Funds Europe speaks to leading Luxembourg industry figures about the growing regulatory demands on asset servicers and how to remain profitable in spite of major investments in technology.

SEC LENDING ROUNDTABLE: Both a borrower and a lender be

Jan 11, 2017

Industry heavyweights, including agent lenders, discuss issues affecting the securities lending sector such as regulation and the types of collateral being used.